6 Comments
User's avatar
David Fruchtman's avatar

A bio pic of Patti Smith, the G-d Mother of Punk.

Expand full comment
Christian Finnegan's avatar

Yeah, that would be a cool movie. I wish I enjoyed Patti Smith more. On paper, I love her. But every time I listen...it's just not for me. For the record, I fully accept that I am wrong about this.

Expand full comment
Scaggsaway's avatar

I usually don't read about the songs you give us before I'm listening to them, but this time I did and I thought for sure I was going to vote for George Clanton. But I just voted for Lori McKenna? What have you done to me, Finnegan? Also, do you have a thing for final songs on albums? Don't make me go back and figure out the actual numbers, but seems like that's been a tendency.

This doesn't really feel mean enough. Or even mean at all. That Charly Bliss song kind of sucks?

I don't even mean that. Well, maybe a little. Anyway.

Jobriath is the obvious biopic hole we have right now. There was a documentary somewhat recently that I haven't seen though and maybe that was all we needed.

Fuck off, Finnegan!

Expand full comment
Christian Finnegan's avatar

Taking these one by one:

* I'm not sure if it's better to listen first or read first. I think my inclination would be to do them simultaneously. But then maybe you'd be robbed of these precious moments of self discovery.

* Not sure if I'm biased towards last songs, but yeah, I do love a late album hidden gem.

* I can't believe you're so mean.

* I actually went to a screening of the Jobriath doc at Lincoln Center however many years ago. It's quite good! I don't remember who said it, but there's a quote from it that I think of often. The guy was trying to explain why more people don't remember Jobriath: : "Sometimes all groundbreakers do is break ground." Or something to that effect.

* I am indeed fucking off. For four weeks, dammit!

Expand full comment
Brian McGuinness's avatar

Whoa. I LOVE Marvin Gaye (have 2 box sets on CD) and play him almost daily at home, even just for a few minutes but I had no idea about that. Definitely gonna get that book soon. Those clips were great.

And give me an O.D.B. biopic finally please.

Expand full comment
Christian Finnegan's avatar

I'm not even a huge fan, but an ODB doc would be amazing. The CGI on his teeth alone!

Divided Soul is great. The author conducted hours and hours of interviews with Marvin, so a lot it comes directly from the source.

Expand full comment